Google+ YA Romantics: Just Finished Reading … The Vow by Jessica Martinez

Thursday, October 17, 2013

Just Finished Reading … The Vow by Jessica Martinez

The Vow
by Jessica Martinez
Published by Simon Pulse
On October 15, 2013

Source: e-ARC requested from the publisher on Edelweiss.

Connect with the author: website | Twitter.
Description of the book from author's website: No one has ever believed that Mo and Annie are just friends. How can a guy and a girl really be best friends? Then the summer before senior year, Mo’s father loses his job, and by extension his work visa. Instantly, life for Annie and Mo crumbles. Although Mo has lived in America for most of his life, he’ll be forced to move to Jordan. The prospect of leaving his home is devastating, and returning to a world where he no longer belongs terrifies him. Desperate to save him, Annie proposes they tell a colossal lie—that they are in love. Mo agrees because marrying Annie is the only way he can stay. Annie just wants to keep her best friend, but what happens when it becomes a choice between saving Mo and her own chance at real love?
My take: I really enjoyed Virtuosity by this author, and I was excited to try The Vow. I was immediately drawn in by the friendship between Annie and Mo, each of whom has gone through some difficult times. Annie's family was torn apart by a horrible tragedy, and Annie was the collateral damage as her parents turned both distant and overprotective. Mo, the only Muslim in a small Kentucky town, had a tough time integrating himself into this homogenous community. The friendship between the two was touching and felt genuine to me, and I loved the well-done dual POV. There were some lovely, well-drawn moments that were used to sketch the history of friendship between the two.

The middle of the book -- the part where, as the blurb indicated, Annie and Mo decide to get married so that Mo doesn't have to leave the country -- was where the story fell apart a little for me. The two are advised by a law student that a sham marriage is a felony. The law student is attractive and blond in the mold of Elle Woods, which almost made it seem like the book was going to edge into romantic comedy territory. And indeed, that is the place where most of these fake marriage stories (Green Card, The Proposal) usually end up in American popular culture.

Fortunately, the story didn't veer into comedy, but I felt that the middle of the book spent too much time focusing on others' reaction to the marriage, most of which revolved around a widespread belief that Annie and Mo couldn't possibly be platonic friends. Annie has just found a boyfriend, who is understandably upset to learn that she's now married, but their relationship was so new that I thought his reaction should have been "dodged a bullet!" rather than "how could you?" Annie's parents are also upset, but their outrage seemed based on Mo's religion than the fact that their high school daughter just got married without telling them.

I also felt that Annie and Mo's motivations seemed a little shaky. At times, I felt that Annie offered to marry Mo as a way to get her parents' attention. Annie's stated rationale for engineering the marriage is that she doesn't want to lose her friend. Seriously? Is there anyone out there who hasn't been tearfully separated from a best friend at some point in their life? The sham marriage would have felt more justifiable to me if Mo had faced actual danger or persecution back home, but the book suggests that he simply prefers stay in the US and go to an Ivy League college.

In the end, I couldn't really figure out the point of the story. Was it about small town prejudice, immigration and the American dream? About exploring the lengths someone would go for friendship? About the morality of lying and when that's okay? About Annie having to decide between loyalty to a friend and a chance at real love? For me, it ended up being a little bit about all of those things without delving deeply enough into any of the issues to satisfy me 100%.

That said, I loved the writing and I did appreciate the ending -- the fact that the book (highlight for spoiler) stuck to its guns and didn't have Annie and Mo fall in love for real, (end spoiler) forcing Annie and Mo to really own up to the consequences of what they did. Though The Vow wasn't a perfect read for me, there was a lot in the book that I liked and I look forward to reading more by Jessica Martinez!

12 comments:

  1. I wish the book had gone a bit more in depth on the characters-if Annie had done this for attention, that could have really been played up. But I also liked the ending spoiler and just the general way things shook out. I didn't even think about how the story might have been stronger with Mo facing persecution back home but that's a good point.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This book just released right? I looking forward to reading it but I don't like the face the story is lost half-way through. I do, loved Virtuosity. Hmm, I still plan on reading it though. Thanks for sharing.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I've read a few mediocre reviews for this now ... I'm still eager to read it. I've read both of Martinez's other books and liked them well enough. Hopefully I'll have a differing opinion from the other readers when I read this one!

    ReplyDelete
  4. The marrying thing is the reason why I wouldn't be so quick to buy this book, to be honest. It may be a reality to some but it's something that I would rather not read. Realistic or not, I just don't think her parents - no matter how distant they are - would support or even agree to this marriage.

    Glad you gave it a chance, Jen. I do love Virtuosity as well but I just don't think this one will be for me.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Glad there were some things to enjoy but sorry to hear it isn't a sequel that rocked your world

    ReplyDelete
  6. Your spoilers always make me a little bit relieved. I love spoilers. I think I would have the same reaction as you--you kinda get why they got married, but your also adult-frustrated because she's just made a terrible decision to avoid a necessary part of life.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I've been curious about this one. It definitely sounds like an interesting story, but I'm also a bit unclear on the point of the story, and it seems a bit all over the place. I guess if you enjoyed it overall and it had a realistic ending, I'll probably like it anyway though. Thanks for your honest review!

    ReplyDelete
  8. I hadn't heard of this one. Haven't read anything by the author before, either. I'll put it on my maybe pile and keep an eye out for more reviews!

    ReplyDelete
  9. For some reason I didn't connect the dots that this is the author of Virtuosity, I loved that book! I have her other book, but haven't read it yet. This is the first review I've seen of this and it certainly sounds interesting. I won't rush to get it, but if I see it on sale or something I would definitely give it a try!

    ReplyDelete
  10. This sounds like such an awkward book, I would never want to fake a marriage. Books that have no point worries me though...

    Lovely review, hun! <33

    ReplyDelete
  11. I didn't even request this one. I just don't think fake marriage stories are going to be my thing. :P But I'm glad the writing was good, even if the story was a bit awkward.

    ReplyDelete
  12. This is such an odd concept, especially for YA. I can see how the author maybe should have picked one point to make instead of trying to hit a bunch of different ideas. I'm not so sure how I feel about it, because honestly this is the kind of thing that I feel usually only works well as a comedy.

    ReplyDelete

Thanks so much for stopping by today. I hope you'll leave me a comment. I read and appreciate each and every one and try my best to reply. Leave me a link to your blog or website!

 
Blog design by Imagination Designs